“A tornado is definitely worse than a hurricane,” my twelve year old son emphatically announced from the backseat. “No it’s not. A hurricane is worse!” My nine year old daughter’s obvious disagreement resounded off the windows of our SUV as we headed home from spending the weekend at my parents’ house in east Texas. As their disagreement escalated, the other kids began adding their opinions and justifications to the heated debate.
“A tornado can crush a house in a second and pull trees out of the ground.”
“A hurricane can pull trees out of the ground too and sometimes water will cover a house all the way over the roof.”
“A tornado can pick up a car and throw it a really far.”
“A hurricane is bigger and can destroy a whole city.”
“Well, would you rather be in the middle of a tornado or hurricane?”
Silence engulfed the car for a several seconds as the unanswered question hung heavily in the air. For a moment, I let myself believe that the argument had ended without my involvement. As I released my breath, my daughter countered.
“A hurricane can even have its own tornados. Right, Mommy?”
With a sigh, I accepted that my involvement in the debate could no longer be avoided. As they anxiously awaited my response, a single thought lodged firmly in my mind. “This is the dumbest argument I have ever heard.” Trying to reach deeper, I searched for a way to salvage the conversation. I decided to take the middle ground and shared what I considered to be the obvious answer.
“They are both very dangerous and I wouldn’t want to be caught in either one.” Unfortunately, my revelation didn’t exactly bring an end to the debate and eventually a single word achieved what all other statements could not. “Enough,” I announced in my ‘don’t mess with me’ mommy voice and the car fell silent.
As we continued south down Hwy 59, I took a moment to reflect on the debate and grudgingly admitted that I’m often guilty of becoming trapped in the same type of vicious circle. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve found myself passionately debating a topic that has no obvious winner and, even worse, has missed the point completely.
However, I’m not alone in my affliction. There are many examples of this principle scattered throughout our everyday lives and throughout history. While watching the Republican primary debates, I feel that same sense of bewilderment and frustration as I did listening to my children.
Even the church is not immune. Debates over details created the complex world of Christian denominations we live with today. Despite the fact that we all agree the Christ died for our sins, we lose perspective and often fall back into the same cycle of arguing over the details.
In the years since that fateful day, the tornado vs hurricane debate has resurfaced on many occasions in our household. The conversation always starts with laughing over the memory. Despite the unity of belief that this really is a stupid argument, the conversation quickly dissolves into everyone taking sides once again and rehashing the points. It turns out those deeply held beliefs are very difficult to overcome. Yet, the only path to contentment is to focus on the point and let go of the details.
And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another… Hebrews 10:24-25 (NIV)
Recent Comments